Black Sails
Summary
While thePirates of the Caribbeanseries has thread through several unnecessary continuation , the pirate ship television receiver showBlack Sailsis better than Disney ’s enfranchisement in many ways . Black Sails , a prequel series to Robert Louis Stevenson ’s Hellenic adventure novelTreasure Island , offers a gritty depiction of the Golden Age of Piracythat is far more naturalistic than Disney ’s fantastical version . Black Sailsis led by a compounding of original character and persona fromTreasure Island , who are all characterized by complicated ethics and motivations .
Black Sailsfocuses on Captain James Flint ( Toby Stephens ) and his crew as they contend with the war for control over the island of Nassau , historically a port for pirates . Manyreal pirates come along inBlack Sailswho all have a hand in stir rivalries and alliances and combat the remaining threat of the British political science . With many historical and literary influence contributing to an overall more complex account , the comparison betweenBlack SailsandPirates of the Caribbeandoes not fall in Disney ’s favor , with the latter having spent decennium trying to recapture the success of its first movie .
moving picture / time of year
Rotten Tomatoes mark
Audience grade
Black Sailsseason 1
Custom Image by Yeider Chacon
65 %
79 %
Black Sailsseason 2
Acting as a prequel to Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, Black Sails chronicles the story of Captain James Flint, detailing how Flint turned from a British Naval officer to a notorious pirate and his adventures with his crew in the Caribbean. Toby Stephens stars as Flint, and the series features many fictionalized versions of real-life pirates such as Anne Bonny and Blackbeard.
100 %
90 %
Black Sailsseason 3
N / A
86 %
Black Sailsseason 4
80 %
77 %
Pirates of the Caribbean : The Curse of the Black Pearl(2003 )
Pirates of the Caribbean : Dead Man ’s Chest(2006 )
53 %
72 %
Pirates of the Caribbean : At World ’s End(2007 )
44 %
Pirates of the Caribbean : On Stranger Tides(2011 )
33 %
54 %
Pirates of the Caribbean : stagnant Men say No Tales(2017 )
30 %
60 %
10Black Sails Has Stronger Source Material Than Pirates Of The Caribbean
Black Sails is based on a novel, while Pirates of the Caribbean is inspired by a ride.
disgraceful Sails’plot is derived from the limited information provided about characters like Flint inTreasure Island , as well as the history of the Golden Age of Piracy . Treasure Islanddoes not render a net ton of material to work with , butthe show ’s writers were able to explore the story of how Flint acquired and hid a substantial treasure that Jim Hawkins and Long John Silver would look for years later . Black Sailsalso elaborates upon Flint ’s partnerships and fallouts with John Silver ( Luke Arnold ) and Billy Bones ( Tom Hopper ) , who are both all important to the plot ofTreasure Island .
literary pirate of the Caribbeanis inspired by the classic Disneyland drive , which has no plot;only a worldwide cacophony of phrases and options that characterized the Disney Imagineers ' idea of 18th - century piracy . It gives screenwriter almost nothing to make with . This did not stopPirates of the Caribbean : The Curse of the Black Pearlfrom being a surprisal smasher , largely because of its square story that supported the bizarre personality of Captain Jack Sparrow ( Johnny Depp ) . However , the foundation of a root word parking lot ride did n’t ferment for the franchise when they ran out of substantial tarradiddle estimation after two movies .
It ’s been a few years since Black Sails cease , but the pirate series is definitely deserving re - learn . Here ’s why .
9Black Sails Is More Consistent Than The Pirates Of The Caribbean Movies
Pirates of the Caribbean’s inconsistent quality pales in comparison to the four strong seasons of Black Sails.
The Curse of the Black Pearlwas undeniably a success and is loosely view as a calibre military action - adventure movie . This laid the groundwork forPirates of the Caribbean : Dead Man ’s Chest , which , despite some story weaknesses , baffle the $ 1 billion mark at the box officeand upheld the thrills and character kinetics of its predecessor . However , after that , the franchise start out to lose steam . The subsequent three movies achieved lower and lower rating . This is in addition to story inconsistencies that began to appear , bring to the telephone number ofplot holes throughout all fivePirates of the Caribbeanmovies .
In demarcation , Black Sailsmostly maintained its ratings throughout four season . The story keeps its focus on the politics of the Caribbean pirates ' tension with each other and the British military . The long - scarper plot of the give up Urca gold also provides some stability to the history ; throughout the intact serial , everyone has their middle on the gold and business concern rest about who will at last claim it . This bring in the chronicle full set from its initial premise , as Flint inter part of that treasure to be get hold inTreasure Island .
8Black Sails Has Better Characters Than Pirates Of The Caribbean
Black Sails' characters are more nuanced than the ones in Pirates of the Caribbean.
The Black Sails hurl let in many individuals characterized by complicated commitment and goal . They all have different opinions on what is best for Nassau and what the pirates ' next move should be .
TheBlack Sailscastincludes many individual characterise by complicated loyalties and goals . They all have dissimilar notion on what is best for Nassau and what the plagiarist ' next move should be . This sometimes leads to conflict with people they authentically wish about as contention overlap with sexual and romanticist relationships . black-market Sails’characters are fascinating because they do form real connection and show the capacity for compassion , but often resort to furiousness and brutality to survive . They are ultimately flawed but actual multitude .
On the other hand , Pirates of the Caribbean’scast be many admittedly popular character whose strengths are more in flairthan too complicated psychological science . Jack ’s number one end is to survive at all costs , but is sometimes guilted into heroism . Will Turner ( Orlando Bloom ) and Elizabeth Swann ’s ( Kiera Knightley)characters are primarily repel by their romance , and occasionally the desire to protect a family member or friend . Dead Man ’s ChestandAt World ’s Endtry to delve into a subplot about the characters acting selfishly , but they finally revert to their original motivation .
7Black Sails Depicts More Sophisticated Politics Than Pirates Of The Caribbean
Pirates of the Caribbean hand waves the political-economic conflict; Black Sails does not.
Blacks Sailsdelves into a very complicated write up concentrate on around how a group of the characters , chiefly Flint , want to legitimize Nassau in the eye of the British governmentto protect operations of buccaneering happening there and in the rest of the Caribbean . Other character have different opinion about whether this is possible and what form of conflict they should be prepare for . Subplots revolve around maintaining ability within a specific crew , leading to mutinies and personal betrayal . It is all ultimately about economical interests , and what will allow the plagiarist to continue to raid ships and stay put alive .
Pirates of the Caribbeanagain tries to convey some signified of a complicated political situationthrough the character ' interactions with the East India Trading Company . purportedly , the company but want to end piracy to prevent onset on their ship and economic losses . The picture require to make the imprint of a complicated political billet with some main persona ' temporary alliances with Cutler Beckett ( Tom Hollander ) , but it is all fork out redundant by the final battle , which brush off every conversation that happened before it when all the pirate ship taunt against the company .
6Black Sails Does Not Have Pirates Of The Caribbean’s Supernatural Elements
The supernatural aspects of Pirates of the Caribbean were amazing at first, but convoluted later.
WhenCurse of the Black Pearlpremiered , audiences were thrill by the storyline of the imprecate , effectively immortal plagiariser . The supernatural narrative is even arguably a strength ofDead Man ’s ChestandAt World ’s End , creating more haunting and singular adventures with award - winning special effects . However , with the progressively convoluted plots ofOn Stranger TidesandDead Men Tell No Tales , the constitutional supernatural aspects ofPirates of the Caribbeanbecame a impuissance . Meanwhile , plot holes concerning theAztec cursestoryline of the first movie became more apparent .
Some people might findBlack Sails’strictly realistic plot of ground lack afterPirates of the Caribbean . The presence of bane and ghost brings an element of closed book to the vast ocean mount that can be beneficial to the story . However , in the long running , Black Sails’lack of supernatural elements worked out betterthanPirates of the Caribbean’smagic - base storylines .
5Black Sails Has Greater Historical Accuracy Than Pirates Of The Caribbean
Black Sails' general setting and conflicts are more historically accurate than Pirates of the Caribbean.
fatal Sails’historical accuracy exceed most other fabrication or semi - fictitious portrayal of piracyin dada polish . The overall more dangerous and gamey flavour when compared toPirates of the Caribbeanplays into this , as well as the presence of LGBTQ+ character and historic pirates . Many of the characters based on real - life sentence plagiariser interact with hoi polloi they historically work with , even if the timelines of some of these partnerships are altered .
However , even more impressive is howBlack Sails’accuracy extends to some of the most minute details , admit the buccaneer ’ strategy during battles . Ahistorian say aBlack Sailsbattle setting has“a lot of historic accuracy . ”It is clear that the team did an extensive amount of inquiry on the eighteenth - century Caribbean to conquer a elaborate picture of this setting from which the interview can actually learn something . Overall , Black Sailsis much near to being historical fiction , whilePirates of the Caribbeanis a loose interpretationof the clip and context .
Pirate historian Rebecca Simon study a struggle scene from Black Sails season 1 , episode 1 , finding that it actually receive a spate of maneuver correct .
4Black Sails Has LGBTQ+ Characters Missing From Pirates Of The Caribbean
Pirates of the Caribbean ignores the queer history of piracy incorporated into Black Sails.
Aside from any moments or grapheme that can be interpreted as being queer - code , Pirates of the Caribbeanfeatures no characters who are explicitly odd . Disney is notorious for its many“first homosexual characters”now ; in the other and mid-2000s , LGBTQ+ agency in the studio ’s properties was non - existent . No character who would shift this were add toPirates of the Caribbeanin one of the tardy movies . It is obvious that this is a lacking word picture of buccaneering as pirate ship crew were historically accept of LGBTQ+ individual and relationship . In direct contrast , Black Sailsdepicts multiple same - sex kinship .
The most significant one is between Flint andThomas Hamilton ( Rupert Penry - Jones ) , who are reunited at the end of the series . Max ( Jessica Parker Kennedy ) is in a relationship with Eleanor Guthrie ( Hannah New ) at the start of the serial publication , which ends comparatively quickly . Max later has a polyamorous relationship withJack Rackham ( Toby Schmitz ) and Anne Bonny ( Clara Paget).The cellular inclusion of queer graphic symbol is a given in any pirate narration , gain the deficiency of that a major flaw inPirates of the Caribbean .
3Black Sails Features More Historical Pirates Than Pirates Of The Caribbean
Pirates of the Caribbean has only one main historical character, while Black Sails has many.
pirate of the Caribbean : On Stranger Tidesincludes Edward " Blackbeard " Teach ( Ian McShane ) as the independent villain . Some other historical sea rover , or characters inspired by them , seem as fellow member of the Brethren Court inPirates of the Caribbean : At World ’s End . Other than Blackbeard , these character are n’t given much screen clock time . Blackbeard himself is more of a token nod to pirate traditional knowledge , because just by say his name , the story can invoke the exploit of a fabled pirate .
There are many more historical pirates inBlack Sailswhose arc are fully fleshed out , contain allusions to their real histories . This include Rackham and Bonny , as well as Charles Vane ( Zach McGowan ) , Blackbeard ( Ray Stevenson ) , and Israel Hands ( David Wilmot ) . In summation to these characters being additional examples ofBlack Sailshaving better characters , the story behind them only further elevates the serial ’ status by demonstrating its thinking storytelling .
2Black Sails Captures The Dark Side Of Piracy That Pirates Of The Caribbean Cannot
Pirates of the Caribbean is Disney while Black Sails is Starz.
pirate of the Caribbeanhas always been circumscribe by the fact that it is a Disney movie and must be relatively kin - favorable . The movies censor out the violence pirates both caused and faced in realness . The damage because of theBlack Pearl’sraids is gloss over , disease and pic are never an issuing , and moments that imply the peril of being a woman in a world dominate by men are not taken in earnest . Pirates of the Caribbeanshowcases a fantasy version of piracy , one that is not define to its enfranchisement alone .
It is a popular conception of rebellion and normal - wear out being romantic . This is somethingBlack Sailscast member Jessica Parker Kennedy comment upon ( viaIMDB ):
" I used to think being a pirate was a really , cool , aphrodisiacal affair . It ’s not . It ’s terrific . It ’s a really ugly , foul , scary world where people died from simple things . When a shank exit off , the splinter from the wood pay off in their eyes and they get an infection . Or they do n’t have enough to eat . Or they get abject . It ’s a terrifying path to survive . "
Because it is a Starz television receiver show , Black Sailscan show all the danger and reality of being a sea robber . Some people may preferPirates of the Caribbeansimply because they are looking for more restrained amusement , but the story ’s stakes are well lower when the main characters are all safe from death or will finally be revive .
Season 1 of Black Sails incorporated wobble into one of its major plot points . Here ’s what that is and why it is improbably dangerous .
1Black Sails Had The Definitive Ending Pirates Of The Caribbean Never Did
Pirates of the Caribbean’s open-ended structure makes it a weaker story than Black Sails.
Even if Black Sails did n’t hump on the dot how many seasons it would have , a framework was always in shoes . This present the show a direction thatPirates of the Caribbeannever had .
Curse of the Black Pearlwas made with no set plans for a sequel ; the subsequent two picture were greenlit after the first flick ’s success , with the main cast being secured with regenerate contracts . Even then , it was never certain what the end ofPirates of the Caribbeanwould be , leading to a string - out overall story and multiple movies being advertised as the last one . In contrast , there was always an end in creative thinker forBlack Sails .
The writer knew thatthe characters would finally have to terminate up at the showtime ofTreasure Island’sstory . Even ifBlack Sailsdidn’t know exactly how many season it would have , a framework was always in place . This gave the show a direction thatPirates of the Caribbeannever had . Due to its more focused report and several other narrative elements , Black Sailsis ultimately the stronger franchise .
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
Acting as a prequel to Robert Louis Stevenson ’s Treasure Island , Black Sails chronicles the story of Captain James Flint , detailing how Flint turned from a British Naval military officer to a infamous pirate ship and his adventures with his bunch in the Caribbean . Toby Stephens stars as Flint , and the series boast many fictionalized version of real - life pirates such as Anne Bonny and Blackbeard .
informant : IMDB
