Dune: Part Two
Warning ! This postal service turn back spoilers for Dune : Part Two .
Summary
Dune 2 ’s events make it heavy not to believe that Paul Atreides is a villain , but Dune 3 will likely prove that there is more complexness to his characterization than see the eye . Denis Villeneuve ’s moviesare not the first to conform Frank Herbert ’s novels . In the past , a 1984 David Lynch motion-picture show and a 2000 TV series attempted to traverse theDunebooks to the live - natural action storytelling medium . However , none of the previous adaptations worked because they failed to depict one crucial expression of Paul Atreides ' journey .
While Frank Herbert always wanted Paul ’s tale inDuneto be interpreted as a monitory story about the danger of unchecked power , the David Lynch moving picture and the miniseries break to entrance the author ’s vision and portray Paul as a Italian sandwich . The serial briefly bring up what Paul ’s actions would finally lead to but , unfortunately , did not follow up on the plot of ground screw thread . As seen inDune 2 , Denis Villeneuve ’s film series accurately charm the essence of how the source intended to portray Paul as a baddie . However , there is still another layer to Paul ’s characterisation thatDune 3will uncover .
Dune : Part Two cemented Paul ’s role as the primary villain of Dune , but this was really teased long before the character ’s true transformation .
Paul Doesn’t Just Want Power In Dune
Paul has virtuous motives in Dune
Denis Villeneuve ’s firstDunemovie only dedicate a glimpse of how Frank Herbert care to portray Paul and leaders like him . While it is hard not to assume that Paul is the hero of the story almost throughoutDune ’s runtime , his visions of the future foreground how his ascent would at long last lead to a world-wide jihad . Dune : Part Twodelves even deeper into theLisan al Gaib prophecy , explain how , despite being aware of how his activity will in the end chair to universal genocide , Paulchooses to comprehend his destiny in a way that defy the very whim of valiancy .
Every time he sees visions of the jihad his actions could make , he finds himself in a moral dilemma where he can not assist but question whether the goal ever justify the way .
However , even thoughDune : Part Twoaffirms that Paul is not a hero , it does not inevitably confirm he is a baddie . As seen in the film , Paul ’s decision to embrace his portion is not labour by his lust for power . rather , every time he sees visions of the jehad his actions could cause , he finds himself in a moral quandary where he can not help oneself but question whether the ends ever justify the means . Unlike most typical villains , Paul has highly virtuous motives , but his situation and destiny at last make him both a Redeemer and the cause of mass destruction .
Custom Image by Debanjana Chowdhury.
Paul Is Motivated By Helping Humanity And Keeping Chani Alive
Paul thinks he is choosing the lesser evil
By embracing the Lisan al Gaib prognostication , Paul finds himself in a moral paradox where his actions avenge the execution of his loved ones , save mankind , and keep Chani safe , but , at the same prison term , they also lead to the death of billions of people . With one foot in the terrible consequence of heeding the call of his destiny and the other securely planted in following his moral range , Paul ’s determination ultimately becomes a delicate balance between two iniquity . Ultimately , he does what he comprehend to be the great good , lead him to trigger off the holy warfare towards the end ofDune 2 .
Chani ’s decision to leave at the end of Dune : Part Two was shrouded in mystery story , and it has monumental implications for the futurity of the story .
Dune Messiah Proves Paul Is An Antihero, Not A True Villain
One Dune: Part Two scene foreshadows how Chani’s perception of Paul may change
InDune : Part Two ’s endingmoments , it becomes evident that the film ’s perspective is shifting from Paul ’s point of view to Chani ’s . This change in position high spot how Chani is the motion-picture show serial ' fresh main Cuban sandwich , while Paul is the charismatic leader Frank Herbert warned against . While this seemingly paints a shameful - and - white picture show of how Chani is now on the good side while Paul is on the malign end of the spectrum , Dune Messiahwill rise that Paul ’s narration is more complex , and he is more of an anti - hero .
After Paul toast the Water of Life inDune 2 , he state Jessica that Chani will eventually sympathize what he is doing . SinceDune 2significantly changes Chani ’s storyfrom the original book , one can only suppose what Paul is try out to imply . However , theDune : Part Twoscene suggests that Chani will ultimately see eye - to - centre with Paul inDune Messiah , agnise that as destructive as his actions might have seemed , they were driven by a sense of necessary . With this , Dune Messiahwill , in many ways , demoralise howDune 2portrays Paul by obscure the lines between heroism and villainy .
Your Rating
Your scuttlebutt has not been saved
Cast
Dune : Part Two remain the epical saga of Paul Atreides as he ally with Chani and the Fremen . pursue payback for his family ’s ravaging , Paul grapples with a significant conclusion impacting his personal desire and the universe ’s future , attempting to avert a dire destiny that only he anticipates .
Custom image by Brennan Klein
Custom image by Brennan Klein
