Related
Summary
David Benioff and D.B. Weiss were once tapped to bring forth a set ofStar Warsmovies that were later canceled , and some contingent about the films exist being scrapped . There have been several canceledStar Warsmoviesover the years , but Benioff and Weiss ' may have been the great . Their project was , at one metre , one of the most exciting things in the entire enfranchisement . Benioff and Weiss ' motion picture would have brought a new area oftheStar Warstimelineinto canon , but now , there are very few details about its report , and the pair ’s split with Lucasfilm , available .
Benioff and Weiss are well love for being the showrunners behindGame of Thrones , a TV adaptation of a series of volume . They ’ve continued their streak of make adaption with3 Body Problem , but they were once choose to write a new narration . Benioff and Weiss were confirmed to be makingStar Warsmovies in 2018 , but by 2019 , their project had been invalidate . While their movies will never see the screen , they still have an impression onupcomingStar Warsmovies , so infer what they could have been is important to the futurity of the franchise .
After a crush - load down yr of Star Wars in 2023 , looker can expect a wide regalia of new content in 2024 , especially with TV show on Disney+ .
Benioff & Weiss Wanted To Tell The Story Of The First Jedi
In a recent interview , Benioff and Weiss discover details about theirStar Warsmovie . Benioff and Weiss ' initial plan was to tell the origin story of the entire Jedi Orderand , more specifically , the first Jedi , also known as the Prime Jedi . Their moving-picture show would have answer many of the dealership ’s long - put up enigma , such as how the first lightsaber was created and who the first Jedi were . While it would be the first entry intoStar Wars ' current official canon , the story of the first group of Jedi has been tell in Legends before , so Benioff and Weiss may have intended to adapt part of their existing story .
Star Wars earned run average
Year
Origin of the Jedi
c. 25,000 BBY
Old Republic
c. 25,000 - 532 BBY
High Republic
c. 532 - 32 BBY
Custom image by Simone Ashmoore
Fall of the Jedi
32 - 19 BBY
Benioff & Weiss' Movie Would Have Started A New Trilogy
accord to theknown facts about Benioff and Weiss ' time withStar Wars , they were sign on for more than just one movie . Benioff and Weiss’Star Warsmovie was suppose to be the first installment in a new trilogy outside of the Skywalker saga . While it was n’t confirmed that they would have been the creative lead of the entire trilogy , they were supposed to write at least the first film . The next movies could have then been handed to other creators , like the sequel trilogy was , but there ’s grounds to evoke they could have taken control of the entire trilogy .
The trilogy was dispute only a yr after they were confirm to be working on it , but the duad made considerable advance in writing it . Weiss suppose they had a basic roadmap for the trilogy , and that they had gotten , " comparatively far , storey - knowing , with the first one . “The fact that they were already coming up with musical theme for the last two cinema indicates that they could have had a significant vocalism in their development . It also demo how they intended for the story to be separate as a trilogy from the beginning , though Lucasfilm did n’t of necessity agree on the narration ’s merit .
Lucasfilm Rejected Benioff & Weiss' Pitch
Benioff and Weiss had a clear idea of what direction they wanted to take with theirStar Warstrilogy . Despite theiridea for a story about the first Jedi , Benioff say their pitch was at last rejected by Lucasfilm .
" [ Lucasfilm ] ended up not wanting to do a First Jedi story . We had a very specific account theme in judgment , and in the end they decided they did n’t want to do that . And we totally get it . It ’s their company and their IP , but we were n’t the droids they were looking for . "
It is n’t clear precisely why Lucasfilm reject their pitch , as at least the place setting would come through for a dissimilar movie , the rejection seems to have boiled down to creative differences . Benioff and Weiss had already begin develop their vision for the Jedi Order ’s origin report , so when Lucasfilm turn away their pitch , they likely neglect to find a center ground .
Why Lucasfilm Parted Ways With Benioff & Weiss
In addition to scrapping their project , Lucasfilm also lop its business ties with Benioff and Weiss . A reportedly major bestow divisor to that determination wasBenioff and Weiss ' $ 250 million dollar lot with Netflix , which they sign in summer 2019.That deal stipulated that Benioff and Weiss would ferment with Netflix exclusively , though since their agreement with Lucasfilm predated Netflix ’s batch , they were still allowed to work on the trilogy . While there was some room for them to act with both Netflix and Lucasfilm , Benioff and Weiss officially stated they leftStar Warsbecause they could n’t give the dealership their full attention with the added workload from Netflix .
Perhaps the big factor in the split up was Benioff and Weiss ' lack of creative command with the Star Wars enfranchisement .
Some reputation suggested that Lucasfilm took exception to Benioff and Weiss ' deal with Netflix , though . The company reportedly doubt that they could fulfill their agreements while working on other projects . Benioff and Weiss reportedly resist to begin producing their firstStar Warsmovie until the final season ofGame of Throneswas completed . Allegedly , Lucasfilm saw that as a star sign that the pair could n’t make do their commitments to bothStar Warsand Netflix . This was also at a prison term whenStar Warshad a much less certain standing after the failure ofSoloand before the success ofThe Mandalorian , so the next project required complete dedication .
The tension from their plenty with Netflix also likely fuel perhaps the biggest component in the split up : Benioff and Weiss ' lack of originative ascendency with theStar Warsfranchise . Lucasfilm and its Chief Executive , Kathleen Kennedy , reportedly have a very hands - on advance toStar Warsfilms and often promote Godhead to play it secure with their scripts . Kennedy and Lucasfilm have also reportedly been considered stubborn when originative difference arise , so Benioff and Weiss made it clear that they need more originative exemption than they could have had withStar Wars .
The final reason for the split could have been that Benioff and Weiss reportedly had misgiving about the toxic side of theStar Warsfandom . After the repercussion they experience from theGame of Thronesfinale , the duette desire to avoid even more backlash from audience . SinceStar Warshad some notoriously harsh viewers at the clip , who had many complaints about the then - newly releasedThe Last Jedi , it seemed alike to theGame of Thronesaudience . It may not have been the principal ingredient in their split up , but it likely contributed to the decisiveness .
James Mangold’s Movie Isn’t A Direct Replacement For Benioff & Weiss' Film
Announced at Star Wars Celebration in 2023 , Star Wars : Dawn of the Jedi is a prequel focusing on the first - ever Jedi . Taking place 25,000 before Star Wars : Episode I - The Phantom Menace , Dawn of the Jedi will explore the events jell prior to the Old Republic and the Disney+ serial , The Acolyte .
Lucasfilm eventually came around to the idea of a picture show about the origins of the Jedi Order , though with a unlike creator at the helm . The plan for a movie directed by James Mangold and titledDawn of the Jediwas announced atStar WarsCelebration 2023.While they will be covering the same era of theStar Warstimeline , Mangold’sDawn of the Jediwon’t be the same as Benioff and Weiss ' pitched trilogy .
One of the primary differences is that Mangold ’s picture is only confirmed to be a individual movie , whereas Benioff and Weiss ' was always think to be the start of a trilogy . Mangold will also likely bring his unequalled directorial style from retiring undertaking likeLoganandWalk the Line , which should make it significantly different from the original idea for the Jedi descent story . There are n’t currently any story details uncommitted about either version of the tale , so there ’s no way to tell just how different they will be .
Though Mangold ’s take on the first Jedi will be his own , it could still be regulate by Benioff and Weiss ' plans . Lucasfilm has a story of recycling former ideas from scrap project , so aspects of the invalidate trilogy could go in the new motion picture . That will likely be the only way any details of their story will make general consultation , as despite the regret Benioff and Weiss have expressed at not being able to finish the undertaking , they ’ve also put forward they have no intention of return to theStar Warsfranchise .
Announced at Star Wars Celebration in 2023, Star Wars: Dawn of the Jedi is a prequel focusing on the first-ever Jedi. Taking place 25,000 before Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace, Dawn of the Jedi will explore the events set prior to the Old Republic and the Disney+ series, The Acolyte.
